Showing posts with label Psychological Abuse. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Psychological Abuse. Show all posts

Sunday, November 16, 2008

University of Illinois Extension - ELDER ABUSE & NEGLECT - definitions, cases, abuser characteristics

template2_02.jpg

Definitions

Physical Abuse

Using physical force that results in physical pain or injury.

Sexual Abuse

Nonconsensual sexual contact with an older person.

Emotional Abuse

Verbal assaults, humiliation, threats, harassment, intimidation, or other abusive behavior.

Neglect

Failure to make provisions for personal care (food, shelter, medical care, social contact), or forceful confinement or restraint of the older adult (either intentionally or unintentionally).

Financial Exploitation

The misuse or withholding or an older adult's resources by another, to the older adult's disadvantage.

The Victim

The typical victim of elder abuse is a widowed, white female in her mid-70s or older, and living on a limited income. The older person usually lives with the perpetrator, who is often a spouse or adult child. Elder victims often do not report being abused. Fearing retaliation by the abuser, being ashamed of the situation, or worrying about having to leave one's home are some of the reasons older adults do not report abuse.

The Abuser

The typical abuser is most often the adult child or spouse of the victim, although older family members and nonrelatives may be perpetrators. The abuser may depend on the older person for housing, financial assistance, or emotional support. Research indicates that caregiver stress, alcohol or substance abuse, and emotional and/or financial problems are factors in many instances of abuse

Case 1

Is This Elder Abuse?

Alice, 75, a widow, lived in a small apartment with her son, Frank, 54. Frank had been in and out of drug and alcohol treatment centers for years, but was doing well for the last six months since he moved back in with his mother. Alice knew here son had nowhere else to go so she took him in under two conditions: he had to find a job and he could not drink.

Frank found a job and things seemed to be going well until he stopped coming home right after work. Alice knew he was stopping at the corner bar because she could smell the alcohol on his breath. The third time this happened, Alice confronted her son. Frank immediately became belligerent, verbally abusing her and forcing her to go to her room. The next night Alice confronted him again threatening to throw him out if he continued to drink. Frank became enraged and started running toward his mother with his fist raised over his head. Fearing for her life, Alice fled to the safety of her neighbor's house.

Case 2

Is This Elder Abuse?

Carol, 24, divorced, lived on the second floor of an apartment with her two young children. Living below her on the first floor was Beatrice, 86, a nice old lady who didn't leave here apartment very often because of her arthritic knees and poor eyesight. Carol and her children visited Beatrice frequently and often helped with her laundry in exchange for occasional babysitting. Beatrice loved their company.

Every Saturday, Carol offered to do the grocery shopping for Beatrice. Because she could not do it herself, Beatrice was happy to accept Carol's help. Carol thought it was okay to keep $20 of the change each week because she was taking the time and trouble to help Beatrice; although, she was never offered any money. Carol thought Beatrice would never realize the money was missing because of her poor eyesight.

A RealityWarning Signs of Elder Abuse and Neglect

Just as there are many types of abuse, there are also numerous signs or symptoms that abuse may be taking place. The following signs do not always indicate an abusive situation, but can be important clues to possible abuse or neglect.

Symptoms of an Abused Older Person

  • Unusual or unexplained injuries (cuts, bruises, burns)
  • Unkempt appearance
  • Pressure or bed sores
  • Confinement against will (tied to furniture or locked in room)
  • Dehydration or malnutrition without a medical cause
  • Fear
  • Withdrawal
  • Depression
  • Anxiety
  • Visits to many doctors or hospitals
  • Strange and inconsistent explanations for injuries
  • Helplessness
  • Hesitation to talk openly
Symptoms of an Abuser
  • Verbally assaulting, threatening or insulting the older person
  • Concerned only with the older person's financial situation and not his or her health or well-being
  • Problems with alcohol or drug abuse
  • Not allowing the older person to speak for him- or herself
  • Blaming the older person
  • Attitudes of indifference or anger toward the older person
  • Socially isolating the older person from others
In both scenarios it is clear that elder abuse is a disturbing reality in today's society. The risk of being abused, neglected or exploited is real for many older people. Family members or other caregivers are most often the abusers. The problem crosses all geographic, socioeconomic, racial, and ethnic barriers.

According to the National Center on Elder Abuse (NCEA), "Elder abuse in domestic settings is a widespread problem, possibly affecting hundreds of thousands of elderly people across the country. However, because it is still largely hidden under the shroud of family secrecy, this type of abuse is grossly underreported." In fact, many experts agree that the reported numbers represent only the "tip of the iceberg." It is estimated that only 1 out of 14 domestic elder abuse cases is reported to the authorities.

In Illinois, it is estimated that four to five percent of the older population (approximately 80,000 persons) is abused. Only 5,000 cases or so are reported each year. Currently, six out of ten reported cases are substantiated after investigation.

Types of elder abuse may include physical, sexual, or emotional abuse; neglect, or financial exploitation. It is possible that more than one type of abuse may be suspected in any given case. Financial exploitation and emotional abuse are the types most commonly reported in Illinois.


The Elder Abuse and Neglect Program in Illinois

The Illinois Elder Abuse and Neglect Act became law in 1988 and called for the state to address the problem of domestic elder abuse. As a result, the Elder Abuse and Neglect Program was implemented under the direction of the Illinois Department on Aging (IDOA). This statewide program was established to respond to reports of alleged elder abuse, neglect and exploitation and to work with the older victims in resolving abusive situations. Services are available to those age 60 and older who live in the community. The State Long Term Care Ombudsman Program responds to many types of complaints from nursing home residents, including reports of abuse and neglect. The agency responsible for investigating allegations of abuse or neglect in long term care facilities, however, is the Illinois Department of Public Health.

After a report is made, trained case workers assess the situation and provide information and assistance to help the older person and family resolve their problems. Many different programs and services, include but are not limited to, respite care for the caregiver, adult day care, housing assistance, and nutrition resources.

As of January 1, 1999, professionals are required, for the first time, to report suspected abuse, neglect and exploitation of persons over 60 who, because of dysfunction, are unable to report themselves. The mandatory reporting requirement applies only to an older person who is unable to seek assistance for himself or herself in order not to compromise the older person's right to self-determination. Voluntary reporting continues to be encouraged for suspected mistreatment of older citizens who have the ability to self report.

Mandated reporters include a range of professionals in the medical, social service, law enforcement and eldercare fields. Reporters of elder abuse are provided by law with immunity from criminal or civil liability and professional disciplinary action.

If elder abuse is suspected, calls can be made to the IDOA hotline at 800-252-8966, 8:30 to 5:00 Monday through Friday (voice and T.D.D.), or to 800-279-0400 evenings, weekends, and holidays.


Elder abuse coming out of the closet


Elder abuse coming out of the closet
VINCE TALOTTA/TORONTO STAR
Lisa Manuel is the leader of the elder abuse team at Family Service Toronto.(Nov. 12, 2008)

THE SERIES
Toronto journalist Judy Steed has been writing about social issues for 30 years. Last fall, she embarked on a one-year project to document the most pressing policy implications of our aging society as part of the 2008 Atkinson Fellowship in Public Policy.
She has visited dozens of nursing homes and interviewed hundreds of health-care workers, policy-makers and seniors to present this weeklong portrait.
Main page | Series schedule

November 12, 2008

SPECIAL TO THE STAR

"On the topic of elder abuse, society is back where we were with woman abuse in the 1970s," says Lisa Manuel, whose Family Service Toronto team provides counselling to seniors and their caregivers.

"Elder abuse is such a hidden problem, such a sensitive issue," but more seniors are ready to bring it out of the closet, she says.

Earlier this fall, the Family Service Toronto opened Pat's Place, a bachelor apartment to act as a safe haven for abused elders.

But Ontario "hasn't developed the capacity to work with older abused people," Manuel says. "Family Service Toronto is the only agency that has a safe haven for seniors. We've got the expertise and we collaborate with the Advocacy Centre for the Elderly (legal aid clinic). They will call us and make referrals to assist their clients."

A woman may have been abused by her husband; when he dies, his adult children may continue perpetrating the abuse. "Maybe they were abused too, and blame the mother. The mother feels guilty. We're often dealing with generational trauma."

Admitting to being a victim is hard. "People are ashamed they've `let' it happen. They think they're to blame."

Experts estimate that at least 10 per cent of seniors are abused. "What we're seeing is that, year over year, more elders are identifying that, `this isn't right,' and they're reaching out for help."

Primarily, Manuel's team deals with abuse perpetrated by adult children on their parents. The abuse can be physical, psychological, emotional, medical, financial or plain neglect.

"Sometimes abused older women will say, `I gave birth to him, I did something wrong, I'm to blame, it's my fault, I'm the parent, I have to sacrifice myself.' The abusive adult child will think, in terms of financial abuse, `You're going to die anyway, I need the money now, I'm going to take it.'"

Once the money is gone, it's gone, Manuel says. "We have to catch the adult child selling the house out from under the older parent in order to get anything back."

Abuse of older adults was first identified by doctors in England in the 1970s, when an old woman was brought to a hospital with signs of physical abuse. Awareness spread of "granny bashing," and now, in the U.S., professionals are required to report signs of abuse – but not in Ontario. "Why is that?" Manuel asked. "There is an automatic requirement to report the abuse of children in Ontario, but not the abuse of older adults?"

The answer: Ageism is like racism and sexism; when it's all-pervasive, it results in a particular category of people being treated differently.

"It's insidious. Older people get a different reaction from society. If a 72-year-old is being abused, the system will question, `Is she reliable? Is she capable of making decisions?' Ageism undermines older people."

In some cases, adult children who have lost their jobs move back home with parents, expecting them to die, but when the parents live on, they may be abused.

"Victims are mostly mothers, but some fathers get abused," Manuel says.

Why doesn't the abused older parent do something?

Manuel understands the dynamics all too well: She also runs the violence against women team, and she sees similar issues in elder abuse: "The victim is usually dependent on the abuser, and can't imagine being free of the situation in which they're trapped." Just as an abused woman can't imagine being liberated from an abusive husband, "it's hard for a parent to sever a relationship with an adult child. It's difficult for them to think about what to do while embedded in the situation."

Hence the creation of Pat's Place, which opened in September, to give elderly victims a place to get emotional and physical distance from the problem, to get some sleep, some food, and to experience what it's like to be outside the abusive relationship. They can stay for up to 60 days, rent-free.

Pat's Place is modelled on a similar project in Edmonton, where the city provides seven apartment units for abused elders in a larger building.

In a year, Manuel's elder abuse team – up to six people – deals with 100 cases. They cover all of Toronto. The socio-economic status of victimized elders is "hugely variable. It happens in all walks of life. Some are on full pensions and lose all their money; cheques will be diverted to the point that the elder can lose their home. We've had to phone pension offices to report fraud, pension cheques being signed fraudulently."

If the elder abuse team has reason to believe an older adult is at risk of immediate harm, they can report the case to Ontario's Office of the Public Guardian and Trustee. "If we believe the older adult is not able to take care of themselves, an investigation will be launched."

If seniors want to continue the relationship with an abusive or domineering child, they do. "We see that as their decision."

If you need help, call 416-595-9618.


http://www.thestar.com/printArticle/535025

Reporting Elder Abuse: A Medical, Legal, and Ethical Overview JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL WOMEN’S ASSOCIATION. (JAMWA. 2004;59:248-254)

Elder abuse is a growing public health problem in the United States, with research suggesting that women may be at higher risk of abuse than men are. Laws on elder abuse have emerged over the recent decades, with nearly all states requiring mandatory reporting of suspected elder abuse cases. Physicians play key roles in helping their elder patients; they are often the only accessible individuals outside a frail elderly patient’s family circle and are therefore in an ideal position to detect, manage, and prevent elder abuse. Unfortunately, they are not living up to their potential for reporting elder abuse. Physicians must confront and overcome barriers to detecting and reporting in order to provide appropriate care to elderly patients. This article defines elder abuse, outlines barriers to detecting and reporting elder abuse, provides an overview of the existing elder abuse laws, discusses the dilemmas surrounding mandatory reporting, and offers suggestions on how to manage cases of suspected abuse. (JAMWA. 2004;59:248-254)

Reporting Elder Abuse: A Medical, Legal, and Ethical Overview

Gina S. Wei, MD, MPH; Jerome E. Herbers, Jr., MD 

The term “elder abuse” (synonymous with “elder maltreatment”) encompasses physical, sexual, and psychological abuse; financial or material exploitation; neglect; self-neglect; and abandonment (Table 1). It first appeared in the medical literature in a 1975 British Medical Journal article entitled “Granny-battering” and gained public attention a few years later with the release of a US Congressional report. 1,2 In the decades since then, all states and the District of Columbia (DC) have passed laws covering elder abuse3 and researchers have begun investigating it. Nevertheless, elder abuse remains a US public health problem. Community surveys from the late 1980s to mid-1990s found that 1% to 12% of elderly respondents reported some form of maltreatment.4-6 The 1006 National Elder Abuse Incidence Study7 found that 555 011 people older than 60 experienced abuse, neglect, and/or self-neglect in a 1-year period. From January 1, 1999, through January 1, 2001, 5238 nursing homes (~ one-third of all US nursing homes) were cited for abuse violations.8

Several cross-sectional studies have found elder abuse to be more prevalent in those with short-term memory problems, psychiatric diagnoses, and alcohol abuse, as well as among the widowed, divorced, or separated.9,10 Recent research has also found that with the exception of abandonment, elderly women are more likely than elderly men to be victims of all categories of abuse (women made up about 58% of the US elderly population in 1996, but were the victims in 76% of psychological abuse cases, 71% of physical abuse, 63% of financial or material exploitation, and 60% of neglect).7 A recent descriptive study of more than 62 000 reportedly mistreated or neglected elderly people in Texas also confirmed that elderly women may be at higher risk of abuse than men are.11 Dr. Wei is in the Division of Epidemiology and Clinical Applications at the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute in Bethesda, Maryland, and Dr. Herbers is with the Medical Service of the Washington VA Medical Center in Washington, DC.

Table 1. Types of Elder Abuse3,7


Type

Definition

Physical abuse

An act carried out with the intention of causing physical pain or injury

Sexual abuse

The infliction of nonconsensual sexual contact of any kind

Psychological abuse

An act carried out with the intention of causing emotional pain or injury

Financial or material exploitation

The improper use of an elderly person’s resources

Neglect

The failure of a designated caregiver to provide goods or services necessary for a dependent person

Self-neglect

Behavior that threatens one's own health or safety

*

 

Abandonment

The desertion of an elderly person by an individual who had physical custody or otherwise had assumed

 

responsibility for providing care for that person

 


 

*Abandonment has sometimes been considered a subcategory of neglect.

Only a few prospective studies have examined how various factors actually predict abuse. A 1982 community-based study of more than 28 000 men and women older than 65 found during its initial 2 years of follow-up that use of adult protective services (APS) was associated with functional disability such as requiring assistance with feeding, minority status, older age, and poor social network.12 After 11 years of follow up, bivariate analyses identified several factors associated with APS use (including baseline sociodemographic status, functional impairments, medical conditions, and social networks), but multivariate analyses found that sociodemographic variables only (low income, nonwhite race, and age older than 75 years) were independent predictors of APS use.13

According to the American Medical Association, physicians are often the only accessible individuals outside a frail elderly patient’s family circle and are therefore in an ideal position to detect, manage, and prevent elder abuse.14 During an ideal clinical encounter, an astute and knowledgeable physician would uncover signs and symptoms consistent with abuse (see Table 2). Once recognized, the physician would report the case to a state agency, usually APS. A study of more than 17 000 cases of possible elder abuse reported in Michigan found that only 2% of these cases were reported by physicians and that the reporting rates did not increase over the study’s 5-year period.15 Clearly, physicians are not living up to their potential to detect and report elder abuse. This paper outlines barriers to detecting and reporting elder abuse, reviews the existing legislation addressing elder abuse, and provides suggestions on how to manage cases of suspected abuse.

Volume 59, No 4



 

 

Barriers to Detecting and Reporting Elder Abuse

Several barriers prevent physicians from detecting elder abuse. First, they often lack the expertise needed to recognize signs of abuse (Table 2). Few medical schools provide formal training on elder abuse screening or interviewing techniques.16 Older people tend to have multiple medical problems, and it can be very challenging to sort through long lists of physical complaints and correctly decipher which are due to normal aging, chronic illnesses, or mistreatment. Even with trained expertise, a short clinic visit often does not allow adequate time for a physician to thoroughly uncover subtle findings suggestive of abuse. Moreover, victims may suffer such shame, denial, or fear that they opt to keep the secrets well hidden.17 Shame and denial can easily result from wounded pride, particularly since abusers are frequently members of the victims’ families.4 Fear can become a major stumbling block to open discussion, because patients may believe that disclosure will only aggravate the abuse.

Physicians who suspect elder abuse are required by law in most states to report it to a state agency. It is unclear why so many physicians fail to do so. There is some evidence that physicians are unfamiliar with elder abuse legislation,18 and they may falsely believe that only substantiated cases can be reported. Some doctors may also have the misconception that the law requires them to obtain the patient’s approval before reporting. Other possible explanations include physicians’ fear of retaliatory litigation from patients or their families, lack of self-confidence in identifying abuse, desire to avoid court involvement or interfere with patients’ personal affairs, and skepticism in the state’s ability to intervene adequately to ensure better outcomes.19 These barriers must be confronted and overcome in order to provide appropriate care to elderly patients.


 

Table 2. Common Signs and Symptoms of Elder Abuse/Maltreatment*


 


Type of Abuse Signs and Symptoms

Physical Abuse

• bruises, lacerations, open wounds, cuts, burns, bone or skull fractures, sprains,

dislocations, internal injuries, untreated injuries, & ropemarks

(especially in hard-to-reach locations)

 

• patchy hair loss

 

• broken eyeglasses/frames and signs of being restrained

 

• findings ofmedication overdose or underuse of prescribed drugs

 

• sudden change in behavior (including being withdrawn and flinching)

 

• caregiver’s refusal to allow visitors to see an elder alone

Sexual Abuse

 • bruises around the breasts or genital area

 

• unexplained sexually transmitted disease

 

• unexplained vaginal or anal bleeding

 

• torn, stained, or bloody underclothing

 

• oral trauma (eg, ecchymoses, fractured teeth)

Psychological abuse

 • emotionally agitated or withdrawn/noncommunicative

 

• unusual behavior usually attributed to dementia (eg, sucking, biting, rocking)

 

• ambivalence toward caregiver

Financial or Material

 • sudden changes in bank account or banking practice

 

exploitation • inclusion of additional names on an elder’s bank signature card

 

• abrupt changes in a will or other financial documents

 

• unexplained disappearance of funds or valuable possessions

 

• bills unpaid despite the availability of adequate financial resources

 

• sudden appearance of previously uninvolved relatives claiming their rights to an elder’s affairs and possessions

 

• unexplained sudden transfer of assets to a family member or someone outside the family

 

• provision of unnecessary services

Neglect or Self-Neglect

• dehydration, malnutrition, untreated bed sores, and poor personal hygiene

 

 • unattended or untreated health problems

 

• hazardous or unsafe living condition/arrangements

 

• unsanitary and unclean living conditions, inappropriate dress

 

• medication overdose or underuse

Abandonment

 • desertion of an elder at a hospital, a nursing facility, or other institution

 

• desertion of an elder at a shopping center or other public location


 


 

*This list of signs and symptoms is not meant to be comprehensive. Adopted from www.elderabusecenter.org/default.cfm?p=basics.cfm. Retrieved February 19, 2004.



 

Elder Abuse Laws

It is important that all physicians know and understand their states’ laws governing elder abuse. Currently, all 50 states and DC have laws that authorize the provision of APS in elder abuse cases.20,21 These APS laws generally establish a system for the reporting and investigating suspected elder abuse and often provide for social services to protect the victims. As of 2002, 44 states plus DC had mandatory reporting provisions in their APS laws; one should not assume, however, that reporting is entirely voluntary in the other 6 states (Colorado, New Jersey, New York, North Dakota, South Dakota, and Wisconsin), as there are mandatory reporting provisions in non-APS laws that may relate to elder abuse cases (e-mail communication from Lori A. Stiegel, JD, associate staff director, American Bar Association Commission on Law and Aging, August 26, 2004). Thirty-eight states plus DC had laws specifying penalties for failing to report as of 2000.22 Penalties vary from fines to jail sentences; physicians may also be reported to the state’s medical licensing authority.22,23

Statutes, definitions, and reporting requirements for elder abuse vary considerably from state to state, even among those that mandate reporting.22 First, although all state APS laws that mandate reporting include health care professionals as mandatory reporters, the definition of professionals varies from state to state.24 Second, some state APS laws cover community-dwelling elderly only, but others include those in long-term care facilities (note: states whose APS


 

250 Wei et al Reporting Elder Abuse: A Medical, Legal, and Ethical Overview JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL WOMEN’S ASSOCIATION


 

laws cover community residents only have separate laws addressing institutional abuse). States can also differ in their definitions of long-term care facilities – some include mental health, and others do not.21 Third, several states limit reporting requirements to those who are “vulnerable,” and others include everyone over the specified age, regardless of their vulnerability. Definitions of vulnerability also can vary considerably, though they generally refer to the presence of debilitating illness that limits independence, judgment, or both.22 For example, in Florida, elder abuse reporting laws apply only to those 60 years or older who are also vulnerable or dependent on the suspected abuser. But in Rhode Island, mandatory reporting applies to all who are older than 60 regardless of vulnerability.22 Finally, state laws also differ in: 1) the age at which a victim is covered; 2)the circumstances under which a victim is covered; 3) the types of abuse, exploitation, and neglect that are covered; 4) the situations that require mandatory reporting; 5) the classification of the abuse as criminal or civil; 6) the investigation procedures; and 7) the resolutions for abuse.21

Despite differences in state elder abuse laws, some common themes exist. First, all APS laws (whether they have mandatory or voluntary reporting) provide immunity from liability for those who report in good faith. Although every state offers protection from civil liability, most also offer protection from criminal liability.24 To be found liable for reporting, one typically would had to have made the report in an intentionally false and malicious manner.14 Second, mandatory reporting laws generally require the reporting of suspected abuse. Physicians should report whenever there is reasonable cause to suspect abuse, keeping in mind that substantiation is the state agency’s job. Third, a mandatory reporting law typically does not exempt a physician from reporting simply because a competent elderly patient insists that the physician not do so. That said, competency can nevertheless influence the outcome of an investigation, as laws are usually written to allow the elderly to refuse services.22 Vulnerability should not be confused with competency – a patient may be competent but vulnerable. For example, an elderly woman with severe mobility restriction due to a hip fracture may be alert and competent but vulnerable. After suspecting neglect by an overburdened caretaker, the physician immediately reports the case to state APS. An investigation by APS leads to recommendations that include referral for respite care, which, as a competent individual, the elderly woman has the right to accept or refuse.

In contrast to state statutes, federal laws do not play a direct role in reporting abuse or protecting the abused. The federal government chiefly provides additional funding for



 

Elder Abuse Internet Sites

Administration on Aging (www.aoa.gov)

Has information for physicians and patients on a wide
spectrum of issues related to the elder population, with
elder abuse as one of its many topics.

Long-Term Care Ombudsman Resource Center
(www.ltcombudsman.org)

Provides background information on support, technical
assistance, and training to the LTC Ombudsman
Programs.

American Bar Association Commission on Law and
Aging (www.abanet.org/aging)

Provides information on laws pertinent to elders; has
contact information by state (direct link is
www.abanet.org/aging/statemap.html) and other law-
related services for legal assistance providers.



 

National Center on Elder Abuse
(www.elderabusecenter.org)

Serves as an information clearinghouse on elder abuse
laws; lists phone numbers (direct link is
www.elderabusecenter.org/default.cfm?p=
statehotlines.cfm) to report suspected abuse cases by
state.

elder abuse awareness, training, and coordination activities in local and state communities.21 It authorizes the Administration on Aging (AoA) to fund the National Center on Elder Abuse (NCEA) as a resource for public awareness. It also established the Long-Term Care (LTC) Ombudsman Program, under which thousands of paid and volunteer ombudsmen work on behalf of residents in hundreds of communities to advocate, provide information, and work to effect structural changes at the local, state, and national level.25 The Elder Justice Act of 200326 proposes requiring criminal background checks of long-term care nursing aides, better training for workers in detecting elder abuse, establishing a federal Office of Adult Protective Services within the US Department of Health and Human Services, and enhancing law enforcement response.

For a general overview of elder abuse laws and other resources for the elderly, check the Web sites of the AoA, LTC Ombudsman Programs, the American Bar Association Commission on Law and Aging, and NCEA (see sidebar). There is no single Web site that lists and describes in detail the elder abuse provisions in each state. To learn more about the elder


 

Volume 59, No 4 Wei et al Reporting Elder Abuse: A Medical, Legal, and Ethical Overview 251


 

abuse laws in your state, consult your institution’s attorney, the local AoA, APS, or Ombudsman Program. You may be able to obtain copies of state laws from your local public li

brary or a nearby publicly accessible law library.27



 

Mandatory Reporting Laws

Although elder abuse laws are generally thought of as positive efforts for the protection of the elderly, mandatory reporting has generated controversy. A survey of physicians19 found that many are concerned about their ability to detect abuse, are unsure how the law operates, and have reservations about reporting abuse. They are skeptical of the states’ ability to investigate or adequately serve the abused. Some are hesitant to report because they fear exacerbating the abusive situation. Others are concerned that requiring physicians to report will interfere with patients’ rights to autonomy and privacy, thereby breaking doctor-patient confidentiality and destroying relationships.28,29 They argue that this could lead to litigation from patients or their families (who are often the suspect abusers). Some fear that mandatory reporting will turn patients away from seeking much-needed medical care. Provisions mandating reporting of elder abuse are modeled after child abuse statutes; both are based on the state’s power to protect individuals who cannot or will not protect themselves.14 Some contend that mandatory reporting of elder abuse perpetuates society’s patronizing view of older people and that older victims should have the same opportunity to refuse reporting as adult domestic violence victims do (only few states specifically require reporting of domestic abuse).30

Others argue that these laws fail to consider unintentional abuse by caregivers. A conscientious but overburdened caregiver can inadvertently cause significant harm, by forgetting to give a brittle diabetic patient her one dose of insulin, for example. Similarly, neglect could result from a well-meaning but uninformed caretaker who does not know that a bedridden patient should be turned routinely. A caretaker who has undetected medical conditions herself, such as mild dementia, could also easily and unknowingly cause harm. These scenarios provoke different feelings of blame compared with situations of intentional abuse. Critics of mandatory reporting worry that these caregivers could be unfairly punished.

252 Wei et al Reporting Elder Abuse: A Medical, Legal, and Ethical Overview

Proponents of mandatory reporting believe that it may encourage physicians who are initially hesitant to report to be more forthcoming. They point out that mandatory reporting supports physicians’ ethical obligation to beneficence – that the intent is not to patronize the elderly, but to protect them from potentially life-threatening harm. They argue that physicians are obligated to act in the best interest of their elderly patients as they are of minor patients, because inaction can lead to immediate devastating consequences, including death. Moreover, they point out that the law does not ignore a patient’s rights to autonomy; elderly patients typically maintain the right to refuse services offered by APS (unless they are incapacitated as declared by the court and a guardian has been appointed).22

Supporters of mandatory reporting point out that all states provide immunity from liability for those who report in good faith.24 To those who say the law unfairly punishes physicians who are unfamiliar with its requirements, proponents argue that the problem does not stem from the law but from the physician’s lack of education and training. They believe that it is the duty of every physician to know and under

stand the law in his/her state, to demand quality training from medical schools, residencies, hospitals, APS agencies, and medical professional societies and to strive to develop a system for reporting suspected abuse. To those who argue the law does not account for unintentional abuse, proponents respond that reporting does not automatically lead to prosecution or punishment, but only to investigations by state authorities, who have expertise in considering all factors before taking further actions.



 

Clinical Management

Because elder abuse is an independent risk factor for death, correct management is critical.31 Victims are found in various clinical settings, including the emergency department, dentist or physician’s office, or at home during a physician’s or nurse’s visit. Physicians should learn to recognize the common signs and symptoms of elder abuse, many of which can be subtle (Table 2). When the physician suspects a problem, he/she should conduct a thorough history and physical exam, and the caretaker should be asked to leave the examining room during the interview. Victims may not be ready to expose the truth immediately; so rather than asking directly if abuse has occurred, the physician should begin

JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL WOMEN’S ASSOCIATION


 

Effective management of
elder abuse requires a
multidisciplinary approach
that covers broad areas of
medical treatment, mental health

care , social services,
and legal assistance.


 

with questions about the nature of the relationship with the caregiver, conditions of the home, and circumstances surrounding her physical signs and symptoms. A cognitive assessment is also recommended. If the patient has significant dementia, the physician should seek out someone other than the suspected perpetrator who could provide additional medical or social history. Careful history taking should be followed by a complete physical examination, including overall skin check (for bruises) and genital exam. Appropriate blood tests and imaging studies should be ordered as guided by history and physical exam findings. Detailed documentation, including verbatim descriptions of events, relevant medical and social history, drawings or photographs of injuries, pertinent laboratory and imaging results, and physician’s assessment and decision to report, is crucial since the medical record may become part of a legal record.

When abuse is suspected, a physician’s highest priority is to ensure the safety of the patient. The physician should ascertain the degree of danger, and if it is immediate and life threatening, should separate the abused from the abuser and call 911. Reporting procedures should be followed; the NCEA Web site (see sidebar on page 251) provides toll-free

phone numbers to call for instructions.32 After reporting, the state agencies will proceed with their own evaluation accordingly.14 Meanwhile, the physician should strive to maintain a positive doctor-patient relationship by having open discussion with the patient. The physician should explain that he/she is obligated to report suspected abuse. Some patients may be upset to learn that a report has been made. If so, the physician should explore the patient’s rationale for choosing to remain in the abusive situation. If it is to protect the abuser, the doctor should reassure the patient that the intent is not to punish but to stop the mistreatment and to get help. The physician should emphasize the seriousness of the problem, including the potential for the mistreatment to escalate if no intervention is performed.

A multidisciplinary approach using a team comprised of a primary care physician, geriatrician, psychiatrist or psychologist, nurses, and social worker is recommended for managing abuse, as it often affects the victim physically, emotionally, socially, and financially. The advantages of a team are many, including varieties of expertise and lessening the demands on the primary care provider by sharing the burden among the team members. Individual team members can also provide specialized referrals to support groups, home care, respite, and community services such as legal and/or financial planning.



 

Summary

Elder abuse is a public health concern in the United States, particularly among women. As the US population continues to age, the number of victimized patients will likely increase. Physicians play key roles in identifying elder abuse. They are often the only contacts for frail elderly patients besides their family members, who frequently are the abusers. Unfortunately, physicians are not living up to their potential of identifying and reporting elder abuse, as they often lack the knowledge, time, and skills to detect or handle these cases. They must strive to work through these barriers, familiarize themselves with their state laws, and be more diligent in reporting suspected cases. Effective management of elder abuse requires a multidisciplinary approach that covers broad areas of medical treatment, mental health care, social services, and legal assistance. Researchers should test strategies to improve management of abuse victims. Effective techniques and programs are also needed to adequately train health care professionals in detecting and managing suspected cases of elder maltreatment.


 

References                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      6. Shiferaw B, Mittelmark MB, Wofford JL, Anderson RT, Walls P, Rohrer B.


 

The investigation and outcome of reported cases of elder abuse: The

1.   Burston GR. Letter: Granny-battering. BMJ. 1975;3:592.

Forsyth County Aging Study. Gerontologist. 1994;34:123-125.

2.   Elder Abuse: An Examination of a Hidden Problem. Washington, DC:

7.   Administration on Aging. The National Elder Abuse Incidence Study.

Select Committee on Aging, US House of Representatives; April, 1981.

Available at: www.aoa.gov/eldfam/Elder Rights/Elder Abuse/ABuseRe-

Committee publication number 97-277.

port_Full.pdf. Retrieved February 20, 2004.

3.   Administration on Aging. Elder Rights & Resources: Elder Abuse.

8.   Minority Staff, Special Investigations Division, Committee on

Available at: www.aoa.gov/eldfam/elder_rights/elder_abuse/elder_

Government Reform, US House of Representatives. Abuse of Residents is

abuse.asp. Retrieved February 21, 2004.

a Major Problem in U.S. Nursing Home. Washington, DC: US Government


 

                  4.                Pillemer K, Finkelhor D. The prevalence of elder abuse: A random Printing Office; 2001.

                  sample survey. Gerontologist. 1988;28:51-57.         9. Sugarman LR, Fries BF, Wolf RS, Morris JN. Identifying older people at

2                Heisler CJ, Tewksbury JE. Fiduciary abuse of the elderly: A prosecutor’s risk of abuse during routine screening practices. J Am Geriatr Soc. perspective. Journal of Elder Abuse and Neglect. 1991;3:23-40. 2003:51:24-31.

 

Volume 59, No 4                                                                                                                           Wei et al Reporting Elder Abuse: A Medical, Legal, and Ethical Overview 253


 

1               Vida S, Monks RC, Des Rosiers P. Prevalence and correlates of elder abuse and neglect in a geriatric psychiatry service. Can J Psychiatry. 2002;47:459-467.

2               Pavlik VN, Hyman DJ, Festa NA, Bitondo Dyer C. Quantifying the problem of abuse and neglect in adults–Analysis of a statewide database. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2001;49:45-48.

3               Lachs MS, Berkman L, Fulmer T, Horwitz RI. A prospective community-based pilot study of risk factors for the investigation of elder mistreatment. J Am Geriatr Soc. 1994;42:169-173.

4               Lachs MS, Williams C, O’Brien S, Hurst L, Horwitz R. Older adults. An 11-year longitudinal study of adult protective service use. Arch Intern Med. 1996;156:449-453.

5               American Medical Association. American Medical Association Diagnostic and Treatment Guidelines on Elder Abuse and Neglect. Chicago, Ill: American Medical Association; 1992.

6               Rosenblatt DE, Cho KH, Durance PW. Reporting mistreatment of older adults: The role of physicians. J Am Geriatr Soc. 1996;44:65-70.

7               Hazzard WR. Elder abuse: Definitions and implications for medical education. Acad Med. 1995;70:979-981.

8               Tomita SK. The denial of elder mistreatment by victims and abusers: The application of neutralization theory. Violence Vict. 1990;5:171-184.

9               Clark-Daniels CL, Daniels RS, Baumhover LA. Abuse and neglect of the elderly: Are emergency department personnel aware of mandatory reporting laws? Ann Emerg Med. 1990;19:970-977.

10           Daniels RS, Baumhover LA, Clark-Daniels CL. Physicians’ mandatory reporting of elder abuse. Gerontologist. 1989;29:321-327.

11           Brewer RA, Jones JS. Reporting elder abuse: Limitations of statutes. Ann Emerg Med. 1989;18:1217-1221.

12           National Center on Elder Abuse. Elder Abuse Law Background Information. Available at: www.elderabusecenter.org/default.cfm?p =backgrounder.cfm. Retrieved February 19, 2004.

 

1               Welfel EF, Danzinger PR, Santoro S. Mandated reporting of abuse/maltreatment of older adults: A primer for counselors. J Couns Dev. 2000;78:284-292.

2               Subcommittee on Health and Long-Term Care of the Select Committee on Aging, House of Representatives. Elder Abuse: A Decade of Shame and Inaction. Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office; 1992.

3               Daly JM, Jogerst G, Brinig M, Dawson J. Mandatory reporting: Relationship of APS statute language on state reported elder abuse. Journal of Elder Abuse and Neglect. In press.

4               Long Term Care Ombudsman Resource Center. Available at: www.ltcombudsman.org/. Retrieved August 20, 2004.

5               National Center on Elder Abuse. Elder Justice Act of 2003. Available at: www.elderabusecenter.org/default.cfm?p=elderjustice.cfm. Retrieved August 29, 2004.

6               National Center on Elder Abuse. State Laws. Available at: www.elderabusecenter.org/default.cfm?p=statelaws.cfm. Retrieved August 29, 2004

7               Williams G. Elder abuse reporting and ethical dilemmas. Iowa Med. 1996;86:20-22.

8               Clark-Daniels DR, Baumhover LA. Physicians’ and nurses’ responses to abuse of the elderly: A comparative study of two surveys in Alabama. Journal of Elder Abuse and Neglect. 1989;1:57-72.

9               American College of Emergency Physicians. Fact Sheets -Domestic Violence. Available at: www.acep.org/1,391,0.html. Retrieved August 30, 2004.

10           Lachs MS, Williams CS, O’Brien S, Pillemer KA, Charlson ME. The mortality of elder mistreatment. JAMA. 1998;280:428-432.

11           National Center on Elder Abuse. State Elder Abuse Hotlines. Available at: www.elderabusecenter.org/default.cfm?p=statehotlines.cfm. Retrieved August 29, 2004

 


 

254 Wei et al Reporting Elder Abuse: A Medical, Legal, and Ethical Overview                                     JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL WOMEN’S ASSOCIATION 

Custom Search

THE VAULT - LLWTD Blog Archives